Understanding Roofing Warranties: What's Actually Covered (2025)

Manufacturer Warranties: What They Actually Cover

Limited Lifetime Warranties (The Fine Print)

When you see "Limited Lifetime Warranty" on asphalt shingles, here's what it actually means:

"Lifetime" = Life of the original homeowner, NOT the shingles' lifespan
"Limited" = Excludes wind damage, hail, installation errors, algae (unless specifically covered)
Material defects only: Manufacturing flaws like premature granule loss, cracking, blistering
Prorated after 10-15 years: You pay a percentage based on shingle age

⚠️ Reality Check: Prorated Coverage

If your 15-year-old shingles fail due to a manufacturing defect, and the warranty is 50% prorated at that point, the manufacturer only pays 50% of material cost. You pay 50% + 100% of labor. For a $12,000 roof, you might only save $3,000 while still paying $9,000 out of pocket.

Enhanced vs. Standard Manufacturer Warranties

Feature	Standard Warranty	Enhanced Warranty (GAF System Plus, etc.)
Material Coverage	Shingles only	Shingles + underlayment + starter + ridge cap
Labor Coverage	None (you pay 100%)	Covered for 10-25 years (non-prorated)
Wind Warranty	110-130 mph (limited period)	130-150 mph (lifetime, with proper installation)
Proration Start	After 10 years	After 25-50 years (or never)
Transferability	No (or limited to 1-2 years)	Yes (10+ years for new homeowner)
Cost Premium	$0 (included)	+10-20% (requires certified contractor + full system)

What Manufacturer Warranties DON'T Cover

✗Wind damage above rated speed: If your shingles are rated for 130 mph and a 140 mph storm hits, no coverage.
✗Hail damage: Not covered unless you purchased separate impact-resistance warranty (Class 4 shingles).
✗Installation errors: Improper nailing, flashing, ventilation issues—that's workmanship warranty.
✗Algae/mold growth: Unless you bought algae-resistant shingles with specific algae warranty (10-25 years).
✗Normal wear and tear: Gradual aging, UV degradation, foot traffic damage.
✗Acts of God (most): Tornadoes, falling trees, fire, vandalism—file with homeowner's insurance, not roof warranty.
✗Improper ventilation: If attic temps exceed manufacturer specs due to inadequate ventilation, warranty void.
✗Cosmetic issues: Color variations, slight waviness, minor granule loss (unless severe).

Workmanship Warranties: Your Installation Protection

What Workmanship Warranties Cover

This warranty is provided by your roofing contractor, not the manufacturer. It covers installation mistakes, such as:

Leaks from improper installation: Flashing errors, valley mistakes, shingle misalignment
Improper nailing: High nails, overdriven nails, missing nails (causes blow-offs)
Poor ventilation installation: Blocked soffit vents, inadequate ridge vent cutting
Underlayment issues: Gaps, wrinkles, improper overlap
Drip edge/flashing failures: Missing drip edge, unsealed flashing, wrong materials

Typical Workmanship Warranty Durations

Low-End Contractors

1-2 years

Storm chasers, unlicensed contractors, or those who cut corners. High risk of being unreachable after warranty expires.

Reputable Local Contractors

5-10 years

Established Fort Worth businesses with track records. Realistic warranty period that shows confidence in their work.

Certified Elite Contractors

10-25 years

GAF Master Elite, CertainTeed Select ShingleMaster, etc. Often backed by manufacturer for added security.

The Biggest Risk: Contractor Going Out of Business

🚨 Workmanship Warranty Red Flag

If your contractor goes out of business (bankruptcy, closure, leaves area), your workmanship warranty is worthless. There's no one to honor it.

Protection strategies:

Choose contractors with 10+ years in Fort Worth (track record of stability)
Ask about manufacturer-backed workmanship warranties (GAF Golden Pledge, CertainTeed SureStart Plus)
Verify contractor is properly insured and bonded ($1M+ general liability)
Check BBB rating, online reviews, and local reputation
Get warranty in writing with specific coverage details (not just verbal promises)

Manufacturer-Backed Workmanship Warranties

Some manufacturers offer workmanship warranty protection even if the contractor goes out of business. These require certified contractors and full roofing systems (shingles + underlayment + accessories).

Manufacturer Program	Workmanship Coverage	Requirements	Cost Premium
GAF Golden Pledge	25 years (non-prorated labor + materials)	GAF Master Elite contractor + full GAF system	+15-25% roof cost
CertainTeed SureStart Plus	10-25 years (labor + materials)	SELECT ShingleMaster + full CertainTeed system	+10-20% roof cost
Owens Corning Platinum Protection	25 years (non-prorated)	Platinum Preferred contractor + full OC system	+15-20% roof cost
Atlas Pinnacle Pristine	15 years (labor coverage)	PRO+ contractor + full Atlas system	+10-15% roof cost

Prorated vs. Non-Prorated: The Math That Matters

How Proration Works (Example Calculation)

Scenario: Material Defect at Year 15

You installed a roof with a "50-year limited warranty" in 2010. In 2025 (15 years later), shingles show premature granule loss due to a manufacturing defect. Here's what you'll pay:

❌ Standard Prorated Warranty

Coverage at Year 15: 70% (30% prorated reduction)

Material cost: $5,000

Labor cost: $7,000

Manufacturer pays: 70% × $5,000 = $3,500 (materials only)

You pay: $1,500 (materials) + $7,000 (labor) = $8,500

✓ Non-Prorated Enhanced Warranty

Coverage at Year 15: 100% (non-prorated for 25 years)

Material cost: $5,000

Labor cost: $7,000

Manufacturer pays: $5,000 (materials) + $7,000 (labor) = $12,000

You pay: $0

💡 Savings with non-prorated warranty: $8,500. If you paid a 15% premium ($1,800) for enhanced warranty at installation, this one claim saves you $6,700.

Typical Proration Schedules

Years Since Installation	Standard Warranty Coverage	Enhanced Non-Prorated
0-10 years	100% (materials only, no labor)	100% (materials + labor)
11-15 years	80-70% (materials only)	100% (materials + labor)
16-20 years	60-50% (materials only)	100% (materials + labor)
21-25 years	40-30% (materials only)	100% (materials + labor)
26+ years	20-10% (materials only)	Prorated (usually after 25-30 years)

Warranty Transferability: Selling Your Home

Why Transferability Matters for Resale Value

A transferable roof warranty can add $5,000-$15,000 to your home's resale value and make your listing more attractive to buyers. Here's what's typically transferable:

Standard vs. Enhanced Transferability

Warranty Type	Transferability	Transfer Fee	Coverage for New Owner
Standard Manufacturer Warranty	Limited (1-2 years for second owner)	$0-$50 registration fee	Materials only, prorated
Enhanced Manufacturer Warranty	Fully transferable (10+ years)	$100-$300 transfer fee	Materials + labor, non-prorated (remaining term)
Contractor Workmanship Warranty	Rarely transferable (check contract)	Usually non-transferable	N/A
Manufacturer-Backed Workmanship	Transferable (same terms as material warranty)	$100-$300 (combined with material warranty)	Materials + labor, non-prorated

How to Transfer a Warranty (Step-by-Step)

1.
Locate your warranty documents: Find original paperwork from contractor or manufacturer registration confirmation.
2.
Contact the manufacturer: Call customer service (GAF: 1-877-423-7663, CertainTeed: 1-800-233-8990, etc.) or go to their website.
3.
Complete transfer form: Provide home address, original installation date, new homeowner's name and contact info.
4.
Pay transfer fee: $100-$300 (often negotiated as part of closing costs—seller or buyer can pay).
5.
Receive confirmation: New owner receives updated warranty certificate with remaining coverage details.

💰 Selling Tip: Highlight Transferable Warranty in Listing

In your home listing, mention: "Roof replaced in 2023 with GAF Timberline HDZ shingles, 25-year transferable warranty with non-prorated labor coverage remaining." This reassures buyers they won't face roof expenses for decades.

How to File a Warranty Claim (And Actually Get Paid)

Step-by-Step Claim Process

Step 1: Identify the Problem

Determine if it's a material defect (manufacturer warranty) or installation error (workmanship warranty).

Material defects: Premature cracking, granule loss, blistering across multiple shingles
Installation errors: Leaks, flashing failures, nailing issues, blow-offs in normal winds

Step 2: Document the Issue

Take clear photos and gather evidence:

Close-up photos of damaged shingles (show granule loss, cracks, blisters)
Wide-angle photos showing extent of damage (multiple areas affected)
Photos of attic (water stains, leaks, ventilation)
Original installation invoice and warranty documents
Weather data (if claiming wind damage, prove speeds were below rated limit)

Step 3: Contact the Right Party

For material defects:

Call manufacturer directly (GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, etc.)
Reference your warranty registration number or home address
Request inspection by manufacturer's field inspector

For installation errors:

Contact your original roofing contractor first
If contractor is unresponsive or out of business, contact manufacturer if you have enhanced warranty

Step 4: Schedule Inspection

The manufacturer or contractor will send an inspector to assess damage:

Inspector determines if damage is covered under warranty terms
If approved, you'll receive authorization for repair/replacement
If denied, ask for written explanation citing specific warranty exclusions

Step 5: Get Repairs Completed

Manufacturer warranty claims:

Manufacturer provides replacement materials (you may pay prorated amount)
You hire contractor to install (unless enhanced warranty covers labor)
Submit labor invoice to manufacturer if labor is covered

Workmanship warranty claims:

Original contractor returns to fix issue at no charge
If enhanced manufacturer-backed warranty, manufacturer coordinates contractor

Common Reasons Warranty Claims Are Denied

1.Improper ventilation: Attic temps exceeded manufacturer specs, voiding warranty. Solution: Install adequate ventilation before filing claim.
2.Wind speeds exceeded rated limit: Storm had 140 mph winds, shingles rated for 130 mph. Solution: File homeowner's insurance claim instead.
3.Installation error (for material warranty): Damage caused by improper nailing, not defective shingles. Solution: File workmanship warranty claim.
4.Normal wear and tear: Shingles are 22 years old, showing age-related degradation. Solution: Expect denial; consider roof replacement.
5.Cosmetic issues only: Minor color variation, slight waviness. Solution: Not covered; aesthetic imperfections rarely qualify.
6.Lack of documentation: No proof of installation date or warranty registration. Solution: Always keep paperwork; register warranty within 60 days.

⏱️ Act Fast: Most Warranties Require Notification Within 60-90 Days

If you notice damage, don't delay. Many warranties require you to file a claim within 60-90 days of discovering the issue. Missing this deadline can void your coverage, even if the damage is clearly covered.

🚩 Warranty Red Flags: What to Watch Out For

Misleading Warranty Language

🚩 Red Flag #1: "Lifetime Warranty" Without Clarification

What it sounds like: The roof lasts a lifetime.
What it actually means: Coverage lasts the lifetime of the original homeowner, and only for material defects (not weather damage, installation errors, etc.).
What to ask: "Is this warranty transferable? Does it cover labor? Is it prorated?"

🚩 Red Flag #2: "50-Year Warranty" (Without Mentioning Proration)

What it sounds like: Full coverage for 50 years.
What it actually means: Full coverage for 10 years, then prorated down to 20-10% coverage by year 50.
What to ask: "At what year does proration start? What's the coverage percentage at years 15, 20, and 25?"

🚩 Red Flag #3: "Labor Included" (But Only for First Year)

What it sounds like: Labor is always covered.
What it actually means: Labor coverage expires after 1-2 years; you pay 100% of labor costs after that.
What to ask: "How many years is labor covered? Is it prorated or non-prorated?"

🚩 Red Flag #4: "Wind Warranty" (Without Speed Limits)

What it sounds like: Wind damage is covered.
What it actually means: Only covered up to rated speed (110-130 mph) and only if properly installed with starter strips. Texas storms can exceed this.
What to ask: "What's the wind speed rating? Is coverage lifetime or limited period (e.g., 10 years)?"

🚩 Red Flag #5: Contractor Offers "Lifetime Workmanship Warranty"

What it sounds like: Installation guaranteed forever.
What it actually means: If the contractor goes out of business (common for small contractors), the warranty is worthless. No third party will honor it.
What to ask: "Is this backed by a manufacturer? How long have you been in business? Are you bonded and insured?"

🚩 Red Flag #6: "Non-Prorated Warranty" (But Only Materials)

What it sounds like: Full coverage, non-prorated.
What it actually means: Materials are non-prorated, but labor is NOT covered. For a $12,000 roof, you might only save $3,000-$5,000 (materials) while paying $7,000-$9,000 (labor).
What to ask: "Does non-prorated coverage include labor, or just materials?"

Questions to Ask Before Signing

✅ Warranty Checklist: Ask Your Contractor

☐What's the manufacturer warranty duration and when does proration start?
☐What's the workmanship warranty duration and is it transferable?
☐Is labor coverage included? For how many years? Prorated or non-prorated?
☐What's the wind warranty rating (mph) and coverage period?
☐Is there an algae-resistance warranty (important in humid Texas climate)?
☐Can I upgrade to an enhanced warranty (GAF Golden Pledge, etc.) and what's the cost?
☐How is the warranty transferred if I sell my home? What's the fee?
☐What specific exclusions are there (hail, improper ventilation, etc.)?
☐How do I register the warranty and what's the deadline (usually 60 days)?
☐What's your insurance and bonding information in case you go out of business?

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is a roof warranty the same as homeowner's insurance?

No. Roof warranties cover material defects (manufacturer) and installation errors (workmanship). Homeowner's insurance covers storm damage (hail, wind, falling trees, fire). If a hailstorm damages your roof, file with insurance, not warranty. If shingles prematurely crack due to manufacturing defects, file a warranty claim.

Q: What happens if my contractor goes out of business?

Your workmanship warranty becomes void unless you have a manufacturer-backed workmanship warranty (GAF Golden Pledge, CertainTeed SureStart Plus, etc.). This is why it's critical to choose established Fort Worth contractors with 10+ years in business and manufacturer certifications. If you only have a contractor-backed warranty and they close, you're out of luck.

Q: Are enhanced warranties worth the 15-20% extra cost?

Usually yes, especially if you plan to stay in your home 10+ years. Enhanced warranties provide non-prorated labor coverage, which saves you $7,000-$10,000 if you ever need to file a claim. They're also transferable, adding $5,000-$15,000 to resale value. If you're budget-conscious and plan to move within 5-7 years, a standard warranty may suffice.

Q: How do I register my roof warranty?

Visit the manufacturer's website (e.g., gaf.com, certainteed.com) within 60 days of installation. You'll need: your home address, installation date, contractor's name, and shingle product name. You'll receive a confirmation email with your warranty registration number. Keep this email—you'll need it for claims or warranty transfers.

Q: Can improper ventilation void my warranty?

Yes. Most manufacturers require proper attic ventilation (meeting IRC code: 1 sq ft NFA per 150 sq ft attic space). If attic temps exceed 160-170°F due to inadequate ventilation, shingles can prematurely fail, and the manufacturer can deny your warranty claim. Make sure your contractor installs adequate soffit and ridge vents during roof replacement.

Q: What's the difference between a 30-year and 50-year warranty?

The main difference is when proration starts and the shingle thickness/quality. 30-year shingles (architectural) typically have 10 years of non-prorated coverage, then prorate down over 20 years. 50-year shingles (designer/premium) often have 15-25 years of non-prorated coverage with slower proration. Both warranties are "lifetime" for the original owner, but 50-year shingles are thicker, more durable, and have longer non-prorated periods.

Get a Roof with a Warranty You Can Trust

Rhino Roofing Texas offers 10-year workmanship warranties and can upgrade you to manufacturer-backed enhanced warranties (GAF Golden Pledge, CertainTeed SureStart Plus). We'll explain every detail so you know exactly what's covered.

Get Free Estimate 📞 Call 817-779-2256

Insurance Claims Guide for Texas Homeowners

Navigate roof insurance claims: filing procedures, working with adjusters, and maximizing settlements.

Commercial Roofing Systems Guide

Compare TPO, EPDM, modified bitumen, built-up, and metal roofing systems for Fort Worth businesses.

Impact-Resistant Shingles Buyer's Guide

Class 4 IR shingles comparison: insurance discounts, hail resistance, and warranty details.

Understanding Roofing Warranties: What's Actually Covered

⚡ Two Types of Warranties You Need

1. Manufacturer Warranty

2. Workmanship Warranty